There are moments in trading when the right decision is not the most obvious one. I had a long position with roughly 1.6% profit on the table, and I briefly considered trailing the stop to around 4040 to protect that gain. The temptation was understandable: reduce risk, remove discomfort, and turn an open profit into a realized one.
But I decided not to trail it. The reason was not stubbornness. It was discipline. I had committed to protecting the opening trade, and the context mattered more than the mark-to-market P&L. With CPI only about one hour away, the market was about to enter a regime where normal stop logic often fails. In that environment, a stop is not always a clean exit; it can become an expensive promise.
Observation: news risk can destroy a seemingly safe stop
The first issue was simple market structure. Ahead of CPI, liquidity can thin quickly, spreads can widen, and price can jump through obvious levels. A stop placed near 4040 might have looked prudent in calm conditions, but into the release it could have been vulnerable to a sharp gap or a fast sweep.
That is exactly the kind of situation where traders confuse a price level with an exit plan. The level may be technically sensible, but the execution quality can be poor. If the market moves violently on the print, the stop may fill far away from the intended level. In this case, the slippage could have been around 40 USD per ounce, which is not a small operational detail. It is a real cost of doing business.

The price rose strongly and could easily destroy a stop loss at 4040.
Explanation: the cost of protection must be weighed against the cost of execution
Good risk management is not only about reducing downside. It is about choosing the least harmful way to remain in the game. A trailing stop can be useful when the market is orderly and the trend is mature. But when a major macro release is imminent, the expected execution cost may exceed the benefit of tighter protection.
In this trade, the decision was not to abandon protection. It was to avoid paying for protection in the wrong currency: slippage. If I trailed the stop into a high-impact event, I would have been transferring a moderate paper gain into a potentially poor fill. That is not always a superior trade-off, especially if the broader thesis remains intact.
This is where process matters more than impulse. Many traders will tighten stops because they feel exposed. That may satisfy emotion, but not necessarily portfolio logic. A sound framework asks: what is the probability of being stopped by noise, what is the likely slippage, and what is the cost of being wrong versus the cost of standing still?
Implication: protect the thesis, not just the price
The broader theme still looked intact. Oil price action remained in an uptrend, and that macro backdrop supported the position. When the underlying thesis is still valid, a trader must distinguish between thesis damage and temporary volatility. Not every adverse candle is an information event.
That said, conviction does not mean complacency. It means knowing what you are paid to endure. If the market is trending and the news event is likely to create noise rather than change the thesis, then the more rational choice may be to keep the trade structure unchanged and avoid forcing a stop into a poor execution window.
-
Use trailing stops when market conditions are orderly and liquidity is stable.
-
Avoid mechanically tightening stops immediately before high-impact macro releases.
-
Estimate slippage as part of the true cost of risk management.
-
Separate thesis invalidation from temporary volatility.
-
Protect capital first, but do not confuse anxiety with prudence.

The news impact created a 40-point gap in price.
Closing thoughts
Trading is often framed as a contest between greed and fear, but the more serious contest is between process and reaction. In this case, I chose not to trail the stop because the expected cost of doing so was likely to be higher than the value of the extra protection. That is a risk decision, not a hope-based decision.
For sophisticated investors and traders, this is the deeper lesson: risk management is not just about tightening controls. It is about understanding when controls become expensive, when market noise dominates execution, and when the best action is to preserve the original trade while the thesis remains alive. Survival and compounding come from these small, unemotional decisions made consistently over time.
▶ Watch on YouTube
Managing a Short Call When IVP Is Moderate →
Questions About Investing?
If this article resonated with you and you would like to discuss investing, risk management, portfolio construction, or options strategies, feel free to reach out.
I personally read every message submitted through the website.
Discover more from Systematic options and tactical directional strategies
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
